Light Magic {-} Cracks in the Walls of the Watchtower {-} Chapter 2 {-} Part 7

3년 전


Image Source

Let's get into the nitty-gritty, shall we? The devil is in the details.

There will be a pop-quiz at the end of this post.

Matthew 24:45-47 reads,

“Who really is the faithful and discreet slave whom his master appointed over his domestics, to give them their food at the proper time? Happy is that slave if his master on arriving finds him doing so. Truly I say to you, he will appoint him over all his belongings.” (‘New World Translation of the Holy Scriptures; Watchtower Bible and Tract Society; 1984)

I know, I know, boring, right? Well, try to keep up! This is important stuff. Do you think this has been easy for me?

I apologize for being cranky but, I have been dealing with this crap since I was 17 years old; and, now, I'm 49!

When Jehovah’s Witnesses today read that passage, here is what they have been deeply indoctrinated to believe.

Caveat: What follows may seem very strange to anyone who is not thoroughly familiar with Watchtower doctrine - as, in fact, it should be to anyone who has not been indoctrinated by the Governing Body - and I hope you are not one of them - I hope you do not understand anything that follows:

You may need a few shots of good old Canadian Whiskey to get through the rest of this; I know I did! It's really convoluted.

Don't believe me? Read on!

If you don't have the fortitude to continue, then just hit the back button at any point and go somewhere else. I will totally understand.

But if you stay and read, well, all I have to say is, wow. You must be just as drunk on Whiskey as I am! LOL......Just kidding, I'm not.

Really, I'm not.

Anyway....fasten your seatbelts ladies and we go!

“The Faithful and Discreet Slave”

A little flock of Spirit-anointed individuals, beginning with the twelve apostles of the first century A.D.; ending with the sealing of their class – the 144,000 members of Jehovah's Witnesses, specially chosen (Revelation 7:4), in A.D. 1935.

Only a tiny fraction - no more than 13 at any given time - out of these 144,000 men and women - and only men - represent the "faithful and discreet slave" class today.

Got that?

I didn't think so.

They are referred to as the Governing Body. All of Jehovah’s Witnesses must unquestioningly submit to, and obey, its absolute, oligarchic, theocratic authority.

It is the collective leader of the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of Jehovah's Witnesses.

Moving on.

“Whom his [the slave’s] master appointed”

Jehovah God, through His reigning Son and anointed Messiah-King, Jesus Christ (the Master,) appointed the "faithful and discreet slave" - the Governing Body - to its position of absolute power and authority over His people - Jehovah's Witnesses.

In other words, the Governing Body is to be accepted - and respected - by Jehovah's Witnesses as the collective, divinely inspired, chosen, representative - the 'mouthpiece' - of God on earth "in these last days".

Is that any different than the Pope of Rome's so-called authority to rule his people, as the earthly representative of God - His 'mouthpiece' - on earth?

Helloo? Are you still with me?

“Over his [the Master’s] domestics”

The "faithful and discreet slave" - the Governing Body - has divine authority over Christ’s "domestics" - true Christian followers of Jehovah, namely, Jehovah’s Witnesses.

Wakee wakee! (Or whacky whacky!)

“To give them their food”

This "food" - considered to be spiritual in nature - is none other than the Governing Body’s interpretation of the Bible, its doctrines provided to Jehovah’s Witnesses in the form of its many Watchtower publications.

“At the proper time”

Rather, in the "time of the last days of this system of things", as they like to put it. Jehovah’s Witnesses today are required to accept the belief that they have been living in that "proper time" - "the last days of this system of things" since 1914 - the 'beginning of the end' - and due to come to a cataclysmic close at any moment now on the 'Day of Armageddon'.

“Happy is that slave if his master on arriving finds him doing so.”

If you're still here, you're a trooper, and I love you!

According to the Governing Body, Jesus Christ arrived on Earth in 1914 and, after four years of observing humans, in 1918, he found only a small handful of Bible students nourishing the world with spiritual "food at the proper time".

That is, 'Spirit anointed' Jehovah's Witnesses living in 1918 (all were 'Spirit Anointed' at that time) believed that they were the only ones on earth at that time who were publishing and preaching the "good news" of the Kingdom of God. They viewed the writings of their founder, Pastor Charles Taze Russel, as the Word of God.

They believed he was, all by himself, "that slave"(as we shall see subsequently).

Ironically, today's Governing Body rejects their founder's writings - the writings of Charles Taze Russell - because they say that they contain gross errors in Biblical understanding, as well as major prophetic miscalculations that misled many of his followers back then (as we shall also see shortly).

Reading those writings is what got me excommunicated.

Pastor Charles Taze Russell is a never-ending source of embarrassment, and scandal, to the leaders of the Watchtower Organization; they have repeatedly tried to conceal his writings from their followers as best as they could over the years. (More on this later.)

You are a patriot if you have come this far!

“He [Jesus] will appoint him [the Governing Body] over all his belongings”

In other words, according to the interpretation of the Governing Body, it has exclusive authority and power over everything Jehovah's Witnesses think, do and say.

How would you respond to that? Or, do you think you would even be free to respond to that without any repercussion?

Yes or no.

For argument's sake, let's assume you accept the teachings of the Governing Body; therefore, you accept its interpretation of Jesus’ parable at Matthew 24:45-47; and you are, therefore, committed psychologically to blindly submit to anything the Governing Body dictates to you, because you accept that the Governing Body is God's earthly representative.

You wouldn't dare to question that or think for yourself!

Are you still with me?

Since the Governing Body has become, in your eyes, the only channel through which you can receive spiritual food and direction, it follows logically that, for you to ever question the dictates of the Governing Body is tantamount to questioning God’s will and plan; thus, to incur Jehovah's wrath.

The Governing Body has in effect become God to you. Your Savior is not Jesus; it is the Governing Body.

No less than this idea has been claimed by the Governing Body:

“But Jehovah God has also provided His visible organization, His “faithful and discreet slave,” made up of spirit-anointed ones, to help Christians in all nations to understand and apply properly the Bible in their lives. Unless we are in touch with this channel of communication that God is using, we will not progress along the road to life….” (‘The Watchtower’, 12/1/1981; p.27.)

Eternal salvation for you; for all of Jehovah’s Witnesses, is, therefore, dependent upon submission to the authority of the Governing Body.

“Those who recognize Jehovah’s visible theocratic organization, therefore, must recognize and accept this appointment of the ‘faithful and discreet slave’ and be submissive to it.” (‘The Watchtower’, 10/1/1967; p.590.)

Submissive? Isn't submission what Allah requires?

Jehovah’s Witnesses are required by their leaders to be dependent on the Governing Body for their salvation; for gaining knowledge toward everlasting life.

So-called “accurate” knowledge is, of course, provided in magazines and books disseminated by the Governing Body:

“It is only by studying the Watchtower magazine and kindred publications that they can get the needed life-giving knowledge. There is no other source [not even the Bible by itself! - ED.]” (‘Informant’, July 1940, p.2.)

That belief is based on a twist of Scripture. In the Bible translation published by the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society – the ‘New World Translation’ – numerous changes have been made to the text so that it appears like the Bible conforms to the doctrines disseminated by the Governing Body of the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society.

One of those changes is found at John 17:3:

“This means everlasting life, their taking in knowledge of You, the only true God, and of the one whom you sent forth, Jesus Christ.”

Did you catch the subtle change there? How observant are you?

The change is very subtle and clever. Notice how the meaning is completely changed by contrasting, for example, the Douay-Rheims version of the same verse:

“Now this is eternal life: that they may know thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.”


Think about that.

For Jehovah’s Witnesses, to know God and His Son, Jesus Christ, is not sufficient for gaining eternal life; they must study and partake, constantly, of the information about "the only true God, and of the one whom you sent forth, Jesus Christ", provided to them by the Governing Body through the publications of the Watchtower Society .

Let's be clear. Their gaining of eternal life depends on incessant self-indoctrination - upon "their taking in knowledge...." - available to them only through reading and studying "life-giving" Watchtower literature.

Week after week, month after month, year after year - and daily - Jehovah's Witnesses must indoctrinate themselves through reading Watchtower publications, in order to gain eternal life.

Are you getting it? Is this sinking in?

Non-Jehovah’s Witnesses, Roman Catholics, for example, believe that that same verse, John 17:3, tells them, quite simply, that to know the Son is to know the Father - and that is sufficient for gaining eternal life

Contrary to what the Governing Body teaches, the Roman Catholic Church says,

“Our justification comes from the grace of God [not from studying Watchtower publications - ED.] Grace is favor, the free and undeserved help that God gives us to respond to His call to become children of God, adoptive sons, partakers of the divine nature and of eternal life.” ('Catechism of the Catholic Church'; p. 413.)

Furthermore, a red warning flag ought to go up in the minds of Jehovah’s Witnesses that tells them something just isn’t quite right when they hear about how the Governing Body’s interpretation of Matthew 24:45-47 has not always remained consistent.

For example, it used to be taught that, “the faithful and discreet slave” was not a group, or a class of men but, rather, it was one individual in particular. It was believed, and taught, by the early members of the Society that this particular individual - this "faithful and discreet slave" - was none other than its founder, Pastor Charles Taze Russell!!!

Isn't that wild?!

Consequently, a cult of personality had developed around Russell. I will have lots to say about that in future chapters with a lot of evidence to show you.

It was later abolished, and denied of any existence, by Russell's successor, namely, the second President of the Watchtower Bilbe & Tract Society, Judge Joseph Franklin Rutherford.

Although Russell himself had originally taught that the “faithful and discreet slave” was a class or group of men, he later changed his mind, as attested to by the following quotation from one of his own writings:

“The Lord at the time indicated would specially use one member of His church as the channel or instrument through which He would send the appropriate messages….” (‘The Watchtower’, April 15, 1904, p.125.)

Upon Russell's death, the Watchtower acknowledged that,

“Thousands of the readers of Pastor Russell’s writings believed that he filled the office of that “faithful and wise servant.” …His modesty and humility precluded him from openly claiming this title, but he admitted as much in private conversation.” (‘The Watchtower’, Dec.1, 1916, p.357.)

Thus, the very foundation for the Governing Body’s claim of divine authority rests upon shaky ground.

The official interpretation of Matthew 24:45-47 has not always been consistent. (Did God - Who is supposed to be the Source of the Watchtower's inspiration - change His Mind - several times?)

Russell himself, the founder of the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society, wavered in his interpretation. At first, he taught that it referred to a collective group of people; then, later, he privately thought it referred to "one member of His church" only, namely, to himself; thus, the 'Light of Truth' was turned on, so to speak, in that the earliest Watchtower Society interpretation of Matthew 24:45-47 agreed with today’s. But, when Russell (God was his inspiration) had changed his mind about it, the 'Light of Truth' was turned off, for at least a decade, until it was turned back on again.

During that decade, when the "Light" was turned off – and while a different "Light" was turned on – the position that the leadership of the Watchtower Society took at that time with regard to the interpretation of Matthew 24:45-47 was completely opposite to what it now teaches – so, it was in error at some point in time.

Gross error.

Either interpretation - one man or a group of men - can't both be right.

Was God, Who was apparently the inspiration behind the Watchtower leadership and its interpretation of the Bible, just playing a practical joke or something?

Pop Quiz

How old am I?


rEAd My bOOk: Cracks in the Walls of the Watchtower

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  trending

Answer- 49?

I'm in a bit of rut with JW right now. I didn't realize they were so strict! So I believe in God from the bible and enjoy learning about bible so I started doing bible studies and go to meeting sometimes. Its difficult for me because I'm also on a compeltly different spiritual path with energy from crystals and things forbidden by them. Well now I'm learning about the zero holidays. Christams, mothers day, No blood transfusions? I'm only alive today to type this because a blood transfusion saved my life. No crosses? I have a cross tattooed on my arm. Disowning as friend if you stop studying? Wtf. No friends outside of JW? Wtf! God is strict but holy hell. I might go back to having a relationship with god on my own. I just wanted to learn about the bible not join a cult.


Your answer to the pop-quiz is correct!

@magicalmoonlight The social, psychological, and economic consequences of becoming a member of Jehovah's Witnesses are severe - even just to associate with the group can wear you down eventually. You will not learn the Bible from them - you will think you are but, instead, you are studying their false doctrines. I am not a christian; I'm not interested in the bible - I don't follow any of the Abrahamic religions, so I do not recommend any particular religion to anyone. Personally, I am a deist. Be careful who you associate with: Somewhere in the New Testament it says: "Bad associations spoil useful habits" or something to that effect.

Thank you for commenting, and I hope you will continue to follow me on this journey of learning about the Watchtower organization. Have you been reading my book from the beginning?


I have read a few of these but not from the beginning. I will be going back over them all though. Everything you say is true, I mean I guess they do have a good chance of making it to this paradise by following their strict rules but...that just isn't for me. Sadly I didn't know all of this before hand. I've invited the one I study with to my daughters birthday, talked about my sister in the military and last Halloween sent pics of my daughter in her costume - she probably thinks I'm a lost cause anyway lol


I believe you have approached your studies with a healthy dose of open-minded skepticism. Jehovah's Witnesses are, for the most part, very kind and well-meaning people. Like attracts like, as they say - and that's probably why you and your study conductor are friends. This person is most likely genuine and goodhearted like you are. Let's imagine you went all the way and got baptized. To remain in good standing, it would mean no more celebrating your daughter's birthdays, or celebrating Christmas, or taking her out on Halloween. You would have to go to several meetings a week where you would be expected to participate actively in the program of indoctrination; and, you would be required to go from door-to-door. You would be expected to raise your daughter by the same principles; eventually, you would be expected to forbid her from going to her friends' birthday parties, or give up associating with children who are not JWs. Similarly, you would be expected to have limited association with family members, especially your sister, and to associate with them with one goal in mind, that is, to convert them. Your family may choose to distance themselves from you. Your "new family", Jehovah's Witnesses, will replace your "old family"; you will call one another brothers and sisters. If you choose not to do any and all of the above after getting baptized, you will be viewed as "weak", you will be shamed; your "brothers and sisters" will slowly begin to frown upon you and distance themselves from you; and you will feel torn. You will be in constant dread of displeasing Jehovah and losing your place in paradise. It will affect all your relationships and consume all your thinking and all your time. If your daughter chooses not to take the same religious path, she may grow up to resent you and your relationship with her will be horrible. Your bible study conductor/friend probably doesn't currently think you are a lost cause, just someone she hopes to convert. I hope you walk away before it becomes too difficult to do so. :-)


I have been studying for decades on my own with better understanding than the shallow teachings that you will find in any study groupe . All the rule that you are told to obey are man made under the disguise of God . Be careful of religions

As soon as someone tell you that something is wrong because god said so . run
How did crystals get here . if you pray to them well that's something different :)


Yes unfortuanly it is mostly man made. I went to a Church of God previously but everyone seemed fake. JW felt really nice until I learned these crazy rules. I'm just going back to doing this on my own, religions are full of what man believes. I do not pray to crystals, lol. I was just stating that I automatically didn't fit in with JW.


LOL . I knew what you meant
I do enjoy the conversation I have with JW . and any other religion doctrine . They dumbed it down so much it lost the truth . and if you bring up the truth in the right way it causes them to rethink .


@wolfhart You and I and @magicalmoonlight are very lucky we weren't born 300 or 400 years ago. The three of us might have been burned at the stake for our views, lol!


They would have hunted me down like a dog . I in this day and age say things that upset the so called holy rollers . and all i do is ask them to explain what they just stated . All they know how to do is receipt a line and can't back it up especially when taken out of content .


Context is a challenge for every brand of religious fundamentalist. I don't have the patience to listen to them anymore, lol!

Thank you for showing us a piece of your fellowship!

This post proves to be a worthy post for the #greetersguild initiative, bringing knowledge, people, and resources together for new users to succeed on the steemit blockchain. Support @terminallyill the visionary behind this cause and whom summoned me to upvote your post.

That being said…


The ground shakes as incredible power lights the sky. The thunder tests the quality of your post and deems it worthy, rewarding it with a 300% upvote, comment and resteem from @thundercurator.

Increase your chances of a 100% upvote and support the project by:

Investors who delegate SP to @thundercurator are entitled to 75% of @thundercurator income after curation. Get on-board early and grow with us!

Congratulations @eye-am-a-mason! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of upvotes

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Upvote this notification to help all Steemit users. Learn why here!