Photofeedback #9: Autumn colors, shot by @boddhisattva

3년 전

Photofeedback #9.jpg

Want one of your pictures reviewed by me? Post it on your feed with the #photofeedback tag and I will review it for you!

Let's review another picture for you guys!

When I look outside my window, I see these beautiful yellow and orange tones everywhere. I really like autumn and the colors of nature in this season!
And it is not only beautiful to look at through your own eyes, but also when seeing photographs of this amazing change in nature.

One person who really grabs my attention everytime he posts on Steemit, is @boddhisattva. He has a photography series called 'Autumn sketches' and in this series he beautifully portrays the bright colors, falling leaves and moody weather autumn brings.

I replied to his work and he agreed with me for making a new photofeedback on one of his own pictures.
He has just uploaded his 'Autumn sketches #12: sunny day at the river' and I decided to review this latest photograph.

Please go check out his profile and take a look at his other posts. He really makes beautiful images, not only of this season, but also minimalistic black and white photography and even surrealistic landscapes!

The photo I'll review today was taken at a river on a nice sunny autumn day.


Some first impressions:

  • I really like the colors in this picture! Especially the bright oranges in the trees across the water. The sunlight falls really nicely on these trees and because they are brighter than the rest of the image, my eyes are immediately drawn to this part of the picture.

  • The lines of the banks of the river guide me through the picture from right to left. It's always nice if you're guided in a picture, not struggling to find out what to look at.

  • @boddhisattva shot this picture with a slow shutter speed. In hiw own post, he said he did this to add some mystery to the photo. Slow shutter speeds can indeed add a lot of mystery to pictures, because for example water will look very dreamy, without any ripples. My guess is that in this picture, the shutter speed was at about two seconds or something. I think this was too little time to really give it that dreamy look. The water still is a little too 'clean' in my opinion.
    But you can definitely see the effect of the slow shutter speed!

  • The foreground is a little distracting to me. Because of the slow shutter speed and some wind, the grass in the foreground really comes out blurry in this image. The grass moves during the time the shutter is open and that's why you see the motion blur.

  • There is a little too much foreground is this picture in my opinion. The subject is the river (and the trees on the opposite side so it seems), but the grass in the foreground takes my attention away from the beautiful river. Because the grass appears blurry, this effect is increased.

  • I like how the sky came out a bit threatening. This adds a lot of mood to the picture, which is very nice in autumn pictures. The slow shutter speed contributed to this, because the clouds look like they are moving away from the camera. This is pleasing to my eyes, because it also adds more depth to this picture.
    There are some lines to be seen in the clouds, which point at the trees across the water. This emphasizes these trees, nice!

  • The calmness in this picture is nice, but it also feels like there is something missing. I don't exactly know what, but I think it is a more prominent subject in comparison to the foreground.
    This is exactly why I think this is a great picture for a #photofeedback: it has something very beautiful, but also things to do better next time.

I imported the image into Lightroom and started editing and adjusting a little bit:


What did I do and why?

  • I wanted to get the attention away from the blurry grass and towards the river and the trees. So I added a graduated filter to the foreground. A graduated filter is a tool to adjust a certain part of the image, while leaving the rest intact. In this filter, I made the shadows darker and I decreased the overall exposure. The foreground is a bit darker and less detailed now, which shifts the focus elsewhere.

  • I added some overall contrast, to make the colors pop a bit more.

  • Lightroom has a tool to automatically adjust the white balance. If you select a neutral piece of grey in your picture (grey with exactly the same amounts of red, green and blue in it), Lighroom will adjust the white balance. I used this tool and Lighroom added some magenta tint to it and increased the temperature a bit (more yellow).

  • I adjusted the horizon a little bit. It didn't seem falling to one side or the other, but I found that something was a bit distracting. Oftentimes if I don't know exactly whats distracting to me, it's the angle of the horizon. I played with this a bit and adjusted it to my preference.

  • I upped the highlights in the sky, to make it more bright. I also added some dehaze to this part, to make it look more threatening and dynamic.

  • To emphasize the beautiful trees across the water, I upped the saturation of the oranges and added some more exposure to that part.

  • @boddhisattva wanted to give this picture a bit of a mysterious look. I tried to increase the mystery by adding a vignette. The edges of the image are darker now.
    The noise reduction tool can be used to make an image appear more dreamy. Noise reduction is normally applied to noisy pictures, but it's also useful for other things. When applying noise reduction, details disappear a little, making it look more like an aquarel painting. By doing this in this picture, the river became a bit less detailed, adding to the mysterious effect.

  • I tried to make different crops of this image, to reduce the amount of foreground. I wasn't quite pleased with the result, but I still want to share it with you. This is the crop that appealed to me the most (besides the original crop):


What would I do differently?

  • I would try shooting this picture with an even longer shutter speed. This would make the water and sky more dreamy and mysterious.

  • I would try to aim my camera upwards a bit more. This adds more sky and decreases the amount of foreground. By doing this, less motion blur would be visible in the grass.
    This effect can also be achieved by stepping forward a few steps. This would make the river appear closer, making it more interesting and impressive I guess.

  • I think moving to the left a bit would have excluded most of the grass, while keeping some foreground. There is this red-ish looking tree on the left side of the image. I think this picture would have been more beautiful if it was shot from there.

  • Maybe adding more of a subject to the picture would make it more interesting. A boat for example. I don't mean that you have to get a boat and drop it in the water haha, but maybe walking along the bank of the river would have found you an interesting subject for in this picture.

I like this picture! The colors, combined with the long exposure, really add mood to the image. @boddhisattva has a lot of autumn pictures on his feed and he manages to tell a story and add mood in all of them. Very good job!

There are some things that could have been done differently though. I think the overall composition of this image lacks something exciting.
There are some interesting lines to be seen, but something is missing to really make the composition stand out.

I really liked reviewing this picture for @boddhisattva! Thanks you very much for allowing me to do this for you. I learn so much doing this, and I hope you learn something from it too!
Landscapes are extremely hard to master and I think there is a lot to learn about landscapes in this picture. One of these things is making your subject stand out. In a portrait, the subject is always obvious, but in a landscape this is very different and quite a bit harder in my opinion.
I think @boddhisattva makes beautiful images and really has an eye for photography. If you haven't done it yet, please check out his profile and leave him some upvotes and a follow!

And if you ever want one of your photos reviewed by me, please post it on your feed with the #photofeedback tag. I will select one of them and write a new photofeedback especially for you!


Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  trending

Here it is @boddhisattva! Hope you enjoy reading and get something useful out of it. It was a great pleasure doing this for you!

Have a great evening

Hello! I finally had time to write an answer.

Thank you for such a detailed review of my photo and tips on how to improve it.

I agree with all suggestions.
I also tried to focus on the orange trees on the other side using a radial gradient.

Unfortunately, I could not make an excerpt even more. I think that this required two filters ND1000. And I used three filters ND2, ND4, ND8.

You blurred the photo a bit by eliminating the noise. And I used the increase in sharpness. For some reason I like sharp pictures.

I think that you are doing very useful reviews. I hope that curators will pay attention to your posts.


Great to hear that you like the feedback @boddhisattva!
Maybe a ND1000 filter would have helped indeed. What was the real shutter speed by the way? I'm very curious!

Haha that's funny, I normally sharpen my pictures too, especially in ones where great detail is present in my subject. In this case, I think the slight blur of the picture made it look more dreamy and shifted the focus to the beautiful colors more.

Thanks again for your kind words!

Have a great evening

Thanks for another educational post. My free trial of Lightroom ran out so I am going to have to find a way to follow your lessons in other software. You are editing jpegs, would editing RAW be different?


Thanks for the comment @kunschj!
Too bad your trial ran out.. But I think there is loads of free software with about the same basic adjustment possibilities as in Lightroom. Things like contrast, vibrance, saturation etc.
I am indeed editing the small size JPEG's I find here on Steemit. Editing RAW would be completely different. In a RAW photo, there is so much detail in the shadows for example. With a RAW file, you can completely raise the shadows, while keeping the picture pleasing for the eye. If you do this with a JPEG, there will be a lot of (color) noise.
I always recommend people shooting in RAW, because it gives so much more possibilities in post-processing.

Enjoy your weekend @kunschj!


Check The Daily spotlights of 15 November 2017! You missed one? ----> #dailyspotlights

Your quality post caught my attention and I hope you benefit from my resteem. My followers have a refined appreciation for quality art. You might also enjoy my curated collection. To see the quality posts I have curated via resteem, see my blog @pixresteemer. If you want to know more about me and my mission, please check my introduction.

Congratulations @photofeedback! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of posts published

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

By upvoting this notification, you can help all Steemit users. Learn how here!

Calling @originalworks :)
img credz:
Nice, you got a 96.0% @sorucevap upgoat, thanks to @photofeedback
It consists of $0.09 vote and $0.0 curation
Want a boost? Minnowbooster's got your back!


The @OriginalWorks bot has determined this post by @photofeedback to be original material and upvoted(1.5%) it!

To call @OriginalWorks, simply reply to any post with @originalworks or !originalworks in your message!

Kamera Sony Slt-A77v
75.0mm · ƒ/10.0 · 1/15s · ISO 250
Türü JPG
Çözünürlük 2000×1580
Oluşturuldu 31 Mart 2013
Yüklendi 10 months ago
Kategori Yeme/İçm

This post has received a 1.55 % upvote from @buildawhale thanks to: @photofeedback. Send at least 1 SBD to @buildawhale with a post link in the memo field for a portion of the next vote.

To support our daily curation initiative, please vote on my owner, @themarkymark, as a Steem Witness

Calling @originalworks :)
img credz:
Nice, you got a 26.0% @jamesbarraclough upgoat, thanks to @photofeedback
It consists of $1.58 vote and $0.53 curation
Want a boost? Minnowbooster's got your back!

Calling @originalworks :)
img credz:
Nice, you got a 47.0% @foovler upgoat, thanks to @photofeedback
It consists of $0.06 vote and $0.02 curation
Want a boost? Minnowbooster's got your back!

Congratulations! This post has been upvoted from the communal account, @minnowsupport, by boddhisattva from the Minnow Support Project. It's a witness project run by aggroed, ausbitbank, teamsteem, theprophet0, someguy123, neoxian, followbtcnews/crimsonclad, and netuoso. The goal is to help Steemit grow by supporting Minnows and creating a social network. Please find us in the Peace, Abundance, and Liberty Network (PALnet) Discord Channel. It's a completely public and open space to all members of the Steemit community who voluntarily choose to be there.