HF 21/22 was a heart transplant

2년 전

I made a poem a while back that the block chain had a heart beat. We basically have a 3 second pulse rather than a beat a second, but every three seconds a new block hits the chain.

At the time I'm writing this https://steemdb.com/block/36169637 is the last block that my server witnessed into existence onto the Steem blockchain.

@stoodkev is playing nextcolony
@kiokizz is submitting a team for splinterlands
@rontgenoscopic is voting for @cannellate's post
@gameseed is playing kryptogames
@cn-actnearn is voting for @rezoanulvibes
@minnowsupport is sending mined pal
@nuelchristy is voting for @fiftysats
@eathekaos is voting for @transisto's rap battle post
@thegoldenphoenix is voting for @zord189's post
@recessing is voting for a post by @conscription
@cjturtleman is selling some SM cards
@one.life is claiming LIFESTYLE tokens
@rosauradels is voting for a post by @hhiep

Every 3 seconds a block gets filled with new actions, data, posts, comments, votes, and actions.

It's the Steem heartbeat

I guess I was reminded by a recent post by @whatsup about steem being the pulse of crypto. That pulse is created by our community interacting on the chain, and all those interactions get created, and sent out once every 3 seconds (assuming the chain is up).

These blocks are pretty different than they were when I first started witnessing. There weren't other tokens. There weren't games. There was steemit; end of line.

We've come a long way and I think we're evolving again in a very healthy way.

If the blocks are a heartbeat the fork was a heart transplant

The code that runs this blockchain is effectively it's heart. And a hardfork by definition is a change to that code and in my analogy a change to the heart. It's like a heart upgrade or a heart transplant.

This blockchain literally died for a short period of time and came back to life. We flatlined. We're back, and we're stronger than before. That's kinda like Gandalf the Gray becoming Gandalf the White.

Heart Transplant benefits

We have a functioning proposal system.
Trending is way more organic.
Bidbotted posts leaching rewards are way down.
Whales I haven't seen active other than self voting and vote selling are active again.
Post rewards are down a little, but curation rewards are way up. (curation rewards means rewarding people that hodl steem so there's more incentive to hold it and use it these days. That should help generate more demand!)

Overall, I know the finding some bugs in the code sucked, but this place just got a pretty major improvement.

More work to be done...

I'm not just talking about SMTs, but there's a lot still left to be done around here. For starters when Steemit nodes went down and other nodes were still up this ecosystem still wasn't really usable. That's a complicated platform wide issue that needs to be solved. It also needs to be solved sustainably, and by that I mean the answer can't be "let's just keep failing over to free nodes." That's not gonna work in the long haul.

But additionally, I think we need more sinks for steem. After running Steem-Engine for a while I keep running into the thought that just making tokens doesn't really solve the problem. It helps... but the use cases are incredibly important. I'm going to keep working on out of the box ones for steem-engine, but I hope this community takes some of the ideas we have and merges them into the Steem ecosystem as well.

The dream scenario is that people want to do stuff here that requires burning Steem. Maybe they can earn some of it, but they end up buying some to speed up the process. So, they purchase Steem off the market which gets it out of the weakest hands and then they use it in a burn case that permanently destroys the coin. If we can get there it's super bullish to me for Steem!

Use cases for tokens where the token itself isn't burned can help, but if we can destroy tokens to get services that's the best. Badges, advertising, custom avatars, promotion, faster powerdowns, or whatever works. I don't think it should be for daily activities that average users frequently rely on. I think the burns should be infrequent but important milestone events for power users, community managers, and businesses. Maybe we can tie some of this to features of communities.

Getting more burns on Steem will continue to be a pet project of mine, and something I hope to incentivize to the best of my ability.

Proud of Steem and Proud of Steemit

I've been a vocal supporter of Steemit basically since Ned stepped down. Don't get me wrong, I like Ned, but I think he was in the wrong role leading the whole thing. He's more of a product visionary to me than a CEO... but I digress.

This past week has been pretty miserable as a witness with a business. Multiple patches and chain stops. Business challenges. Cranky people on and off the block. It's kinda sucked. But that's not just the case for Witnesses, but users and the Devs/team at Steemit too.

This last hardfork was coded by a team managed by @blocktrades not steemit, and it still had bugs. Does that mean that blocktrades and his team are fucking idiots since we had a bug that halted the chain? NO! It means that coding in a blockchain with so many permutations is extremely difficult. It also means that Steemit team members aren't idiots. They are in fact hard working, passionate, and dedicated people working tirelessly on this project.

There were bugs, but Vandeberg and the Witnesses got it identified and fixed in a few hours and the Steemit infrastructure was put back on line in as short of a time as humanly possible. Do we have to figure out reliable ways to cut down that time? Yes. Was the effort Heroic? Yes. Are these people useless idiots? No, they are great!

My hope is that you reflect on this week to best of your ability and question the narrative that Steemit sucks. I don't think they do. I think they have talented and dedicated people. I invite you to hold that position too.


Anyway, newsteem has it's new heartbeat and I think it's successfully infected Steemit too. I'm proud of my chain. Proud of Steemit. I'm especially proud of Justin and Vandeberg. I'm proud of how the witnesses came together and helped get this chain up without finger pointing or bullshit. They just worked hard and acted extremely professionally.
I'm also really happy with the post-mortem that the Steemit communications team put out.

Things are different, we have a new heart, and this one is strong. Steem is strong, and I'm proud to call it home!

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  trending

I think steemchiller discovered another critical bug that you guys missed.
When you post on 3speak with beneficiaries, no one voting that post gets curation. Can you check that? It might have something to do with 100% beneficiaries.

Anyone screaming about people being "useless idiots" because the thing ground to a halt for a little while is more than welcome to step up and provide their expertise in future to ensure it doesn't happen again ;D

Whales I haven't seen active other than self voting and vote selling are active again.

😅 😅 whistles innocently
Nothing to see here, move along


As a rule I don't criticise someone while they're doing something I can't.


Same here. The exception is when they do a completely incompetent job (happens a lot when government or journalism is involved)

  • 태그 작성 가이드라인 준수는 콘텐츠 관리와 글에 대한 접근성을 높이기 위해 반드시 필요한 절차입니다. ( It is an essential step to adhere tags guideline, manage content and make access better to your postings.)

  • 스팀코인판에서 활용 가능한 태그는 크게 [보상태그 / 언어태그/ 주제태그]로 구분할 수 있습니다. 보상태그와 언어태그는 필수입니다.(Tags that can be largely grouped into [Main Community / Language / Topic] in community. The language and topic tags are required.)

(예) 한국어로 작성한 자유 주제 포스팅((E.g) Posting for free topic in English)

보상태그(Main) : #sct

언어태그(Language) : #sct-kr #sct-cn #sct-en #sct-fr #sct-deutsch #sct-polish #sct-jp

주제태그(Topic) : #sct-freeboard #sct-dev #sct-invest #sct-market #sct-game #sct-movie #sct-book #sct-mining #sct-sports #sct-cartoon #sct-meetup #sct-diary #sct-bitcoin #sct-altcoin #sct-alliance #sct-userguide #sct-otc #sct-prediction #sct-qna
(원하시는 추가 태그가 있으면 여기에 댓글을 작성하여 주십시오.)
(If you want to add a tag, please comment here.)

  • 태그 작성 가이드라인을 준수하는 것이 태그 사용을 규제하는 정책보다 스팀코인판의 가치를 높이는 길이라고 생각합니다.(We believe that adhering tags guideline is a way to increase the value of SteemCoinpan community than that of forcing tags limitations.)


Cheers, aggroed! I agree, there is a lot more work to be done, but that also is what makes me so excited. It is/has been a fun process and watching this baby unfold has been a great experience.

Holy fuck I like this post. Sorry for the profanity. I just really, really like this metaphor.

So like a heart transplant, our system needs time to rebuild itself. A new, more vigorous heartbeat can feed the process, but there's still old damaged tissue that has to clear out, and new tissue has to grow in its place. Metaphorically. You get it.

Triple bypass more like LOL! (friend of mine made this for ya)

!giphy aggroed


// You can support giphy by using one of your witness votes on untersatz! //

Congratulations @aggroed! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You got more than 5500 replies. Your next target is to reach 5750 replies.

You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Vote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!

Steem is home!

Posted using Partiko Android

One of the solutions (which may be implemented in future: see comment section of the blog) to improve Steem's price is to restrict Steem's inflation for worker proposals, witnesses (50-100 instead of 20), and PoS stake. APR for hodling SP can be increased to 4% from current 2%.

Rewarding contents should be done with SMTs/Scots other than Steem. STINC or @busy, @steempeak can launch their own token. Then the success of the token will be depend the the company or founders behind. DApp founders can play with their own algorithms for reward pool, burning policy, buyback with Ad profit or whatever they think it will be appropriate.

Steem will be only required for transactions (RC), RC requirements for onboarding new users and speculation.

Even current inflation will be sustainable if Steem can onboard 10 or 100 million users through its plethora of DApps. Active users will need SP to transact. They may not earn Steem but other DApp tokens.

What a great description. I have to say, other than a touch of withdrawal helped a long by a hefty dollop of off-Steemit life over which I had no control, for me, this hardfork was much less of a fork-up than the last one. I am interested to see how thing unfold.

the fork was a heart transplant

We’ll need anti-rejection meds forever. 😜

Thanks for the transparency!

Posted using Partiko iOS

you're right .. it's easy for people to complain about Witnesses and Steemit Inc. I'm willing to bet a good portion of those complaining and calling people idiots would react to a call on a long weekend with .. what you calling me for? see you Tuesday.

That didn't happen. People got to work and fixed the problem.

Hey @aggroed, can you copy some good feature from quora to steem engine tribes? As for exemple Follow a Tag or unfollow, mute some tags... 😁

Hi, @aggroed!

You just got a 0.16% upvote from SteemPlus!
To get higher upvotes, earn more SteemPlus Points (SPP). On your Steemit wallet, check your SPP balance and click on "How to earn SPP?" to find out all the ways to earn.
If you're not using SteemPlus yet, please check our last posts in here to see the many ways in which SteemPlus can improve your Steem experience on Steemit and Busy.

I'm proud as well of "our" blockchain. Good to see some of the higher ups feel the same way ;)

Highly rEsteemed!


I made it into a poem 🤔

Thanks for your work as a witness and Splinterlands founder 👍

Posted using Partiko Android