Your Vote Value got a lot higher after HF20? Here's why!

작년

Repository

https://github.com/steemit/steem

Introduction

After the pretty unpleasant transition to HF20, nearly everyone got his Voting Power/Mana reduced to very low values. Lots of accounts stopped voting for a few days, and now we feel this because everyone's vote value is increasing a lot.
This Post is aiming to show why and how this increase in vote value happens.

Outline

  • Scope
  • Introduction to reward calculations
  • Results
    • Small Time Frame
    • Medium Time Frame
    • Large Time Frame
  • Conclusion
  • Relevant Links and Resources

Scope

This analysis takes nearly all of the snapshots of the reward funds snapshots that are available on https://steemdb.com/api/funds. Luckily @jesta has made these snapshots, otherwise this would've not been possible. A snapshot gets takes every day optimally but there are some free spaces where data is missing. All of the analysis is done with python. For Steem related interactions, beem was used. matplotlib was used for all graphs. I used the data until the data of 450 days ago. All graphs have been created on the 7th October 2018. For getting the Steem price at a certain date, I used the @coingecko API.

Introduction to reward calculations

To understand the following parts of the contribution, you need to understand how the reward calculations work in detail. Whenever a vote gets cast, a certain amount of rshares get calculated. These rshares depend on the vests the voting account has, its voting power, and the vote weight used. These rshares then get added to the recent_claims, the sum of all currently active rshares. Then, there's another important number. The reward_balance. It is usually referred to as reward pool. It contains about 80k Steem normally.
For calculating the value of a specific vote, you first need to check how big of a part of the recent_claims the vote is. For explanatory purposes let's say, the vote has one 10th of the recent_claims. That means, that one 10th of the reward_balance belongs to this vote. That would be around 8k Steem. These Steem now get converted to SBD (or STU - however you want to refer to it) using the witness price feeds. Now you got the value of a vote you want. Look here for the steemit tutorial for coders on the above.

Results

The Graphs in this contribution often have to different scales. Pay attention that you don't misread the Graphs

Small Time Frame

To start seeing the impact HF20 had on the reward distribution, I built a graph showing the Steem price, the recent claims, and the upvote value of an account with 10k SP over the last 7/14 days.
Figure_1.png
It is clearly visible that from about a week ago there is a strong downwards trend on the recent_claims. This is pretty certainly caused by the Voting Mana drop that happened with HF20. Before the downtrend, things were rather stable with only small changes. With the drop, the vote value has gone up a lot, and the Steem price went up a bit with it as well.
This makes very much sense, that a single rshare is worth more, if there are way less recent_claims. But that still doesn't add up. In the 14 day graph, the rshares went from ~5.2e17 to ~4.0e17. That is a bit more than a fifth of the rshares that are "missing". But the Upvote Value has gone up a lot more, from a little above 0.5 STU up to a bit over 0.9 STU. That nearly doubled, but the Recent Claims haven't gone down that much. That means that another factor also changed quite a bit, since the steem price hasn't undergone much change. So let's look at a graph of the Recent Claims and the Reward Balance in the last 7/14 days.
Figure_11.png
Wow! The Reward Balance skyrocketed. While the Recent Claims went down, the Reward Balance went up a lot. Now the vote value changes make some sense. The combination of Recent Claims, Steem Price and Reward Balanced nearly doubled the value of a vote. But how big are these changes really? Let's look at them in a bigger time frame of one/three months.

Medium Time Frame

Figure_12.png
In the 30/90 day Graphs you can see something, while logical, still interesting. The Recent Claims had an almost constant increase before it dropped with HF20. What really wonders me, is that the Recent Claims aren't recovering yet. Maybe this is due to people voting less, or it is because of Voting Mana. There are a lot of accounts having a constant power down after all, and the SP you currently power down, has no effect on your votes anymore, so that might be part of the reason we will have less Recent Claims even after equilibrium has been reached.
Also, on the 90 day graph, it is very clear. The drop is very extreme. The Recent Claims really plummeted. I'm happy this is not the Steem price ;-) Another thing you can read out of the above image is that there are some vote value spikes as well, when the Steem price spiked.
Figure_13.png
Apparently, the Reward Balance and the Recent Claims movements are close to symmetrical. Almost always when one goes up, the other one goes down. Also, once again you can see how big the change actually is. But how do the developments look if make the date range even bigger? Let's try it with 150/450 (short after implementation of linear reward curve) days.

Large Time Frame

Figure_14.png
Actually you can see that the vote value was very low in September. On the 16th of September 2018 we actually hit the lowest point of the last 450 days with an upvote value of about 43 cents per 10k SP! This increase is badly needed :-P Also, in the history of this reward distribution system, there apparently never was such a drop before. This is the first time this happens on that scale. To call it that way, we got thrown back to the start of February with the HF. Additionally you can see that the vote value has been moving along with the price all the time and there has been barely any movement not depending on the price. For completion, let's add the 150/450 day graph as well.
Figure_15.png
It seems like we hit an all time high there as well. Reward Balance was never that high anytime before! What a time to be steemin' ;-)

Conclusion

Hard Fork 20 cause quite a lot of trouble, and a quite few equilibriums had and still have to be reached. Due to the Voting Power to Voting Mana transition bug, the Recent Claims plummeted, and the vote value has risen a lot. Another factor in the vote value change is the Reward Balance that has been rising a lot while Recent Claims fell down. Also, the sum of active vests got reduced, since the vests that will be powered down on an account after 7 days aren't active anymore, and don't count towards the rshares in the calculation. All these factors together made the upvote value nearly double. All values will probably go closer to what they were before the Hard Fork.

Proof of Authorship

All code is at my GitHub

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
STEEMKR.COM IS SPONSORED BY
ADVERTISEMENT
Sort Order:  trending

Hey @flugschwein, great work! You've addressed a question that certainly a lot of users where facing. The current trends in the recent_claims are something I did not expect. I would have expected a "dip" around the HF-time where hardly anybody was able to interact with the chain and a more or less stable situation afterwards. Obviously, this is not the case and the recent claims are still decreasing. You've mentioned a few possible reasons with the powering-down vests, possibly RC limitations, or simply a decreasing user activity. The 50M rshare downshift per vote may also play a role, but also more as a static offset to the previsou situation and cannot explain a continuous decrease. Investigations on the mechanics behind are certainly an analysis on its own!

Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian policies and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.

To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, click here.


Need help? Write a ticket on https://support.utopian.io/.
Chat with us on Discord.
[utopian-moderator]

·

Thank you for your review, @crokkon!

So far this week you've reviewed 3 contributions. Keep up the good work!

  ·  작년

great post and analysis, welcome to the club 😉
the value of a vote can be calculated with the following:

vote amount in SBD = d * f * 100 * a * b

a = (reward_balance/recent_claims)

b = (base/quote) // it is Steem/SBD Feed price

c = (total_vesting_fund_steem/total_vesting_shares)

d = steempower/c

e = power*weight // weight of vote for ex. 10000

f = (e+49)/50

This might help solidify some of your findings.

I see it like a little 'bonus' for the hard time during the roll out, and dont expect it to stay this way for long.

·

Hey @paulag
Here's a tip for your valuable feedback! @Utopian-io loves and incentivises informative comments.

Contributing on Utopian
Learn how to contribute on our website.

Want to chat? Join us on Discord https://discord.gg/h52nFrV.

Vote for Utopian Witness!

Awesome Flug!

Well, after HF20 most people can't transact and forced most of them to have a week Steemcation. I was one of the people who wanted to let things settle down before doing anything.

Your funds are safe! - maybe that's why no-one wants to claim rewards. Or maybe because SteemAuto was down so most can't auto-claim :)

Hey, @flugschwein!

Thanks for contributing on Utopian.
We’re already looking forward to your next contribution!

Get higher incentives and support Utopian.io!
Simply set @utopian.pay as a 5% (or higher) payout beneficiary on your contribution post (via SteemPlus or Steeditor).

Want to chat? Join us on Discord https://discord.gg/h52nFrV.

Vote for Utopian Witness!

Very interesting analysis, why did the reward_balance go up at all? Shouldn't the reward_balance decrease over time because the inflation is slowly decreasing? Or has it something to do with the changed self-voting/15-min rules that the curation award of a self-vote goes to the reward pool again?

·

To be honest, I don't really know. It seems to be linked to the recent claims going down, since this up and down always happened reverse with the other value. Can't know everything I guess.
But the Reward Balance only decreases pretty slow. Most of the movement is connected to other stuff moving up and down etc.

  ·  작년

The big question is Will Reward Balance hold. People who write posts right now are rewarded like we did when Steem price was at its ATH. Interesting times.

·

Yeah, I think it will go down at least to some part back to where it was. But recent claims seem to be linked to reward balance, and I expect the recent claims to go back up to somewhere between now, and pre HF20.
Only time will tell though :)) (I wouldn't mind my vote to have 10 cents value all the time though ;) )

Sehr interessant! Hab mich schon gefragt, wieso mein Vote plötzlich mehr wert ist!
Danke für diese sehr ausführliche Erklärung!

  ·  작년

Great analysis, I was wondering myself. I do expect the voting values to decrease a little with equilibrium, however (unless the steem prize goes up, ofc.).

·

It will almost certainly decrease again. (At least I expect it to xD)

Excellent post, one that gets bookmarked for further reference.

Posted using Partiko Android

Eigentlich könntest Du so eine Analyse Ende des Monats noch mal machen. Jetzt gerade gehen die Rewards doch leicht zurück. Vor einer Woche hatte ich bei 100% VP 0,10-0,11 zu vergeben, jetzt bin ich bei 91% bei 0,07, so daß ich die 0,10 trotz Zunahme meiner SP nicht erreichen werde.

You just planted 0.10 tree(s)!


Thanks to @condeas

We have planted already 3705.15 trees
out of 1,000,000


Let's save and restore Abongphen Highland Forest
in Cameroonian village Kedjom-Keku!
Plant trees with @treeplanter and get paid for it!
My Steem Power = 20748.94
Thanks a lot!
@martin.mikes coordinator of @kedjom-keku
treeplantermessage_ok.png

Hi @flugschwein!

Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your post is eligible for our upvote, thanks to our collaboration with @utopian-io!
Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server

What have we here,one year !BEER



Hey @flugschwein, here is a little bit of BEER for you. Enjoy it!

If I could turn back !BEER